Search | Site Info | Site Map

MENU

HOMEPAGE

Animal Health/
Welfare/Zoonoses

Environment

Land Reform

Social/
Economic/
Political

Food

Science

Fishing

Tourism

Education

Cultybraggan
Farm

Trade

Book Reviews

Light Relief

Links

Glossary

Correspondence

Vacancies

Contact Us

Get Acrobat Reader

 

 

Back to CORRESPONDENCE Homepage

Dear Sir,

Does benzene poisoning cause scrapie?

My correspondence of the 9th January entitled "Does benzene poisoning cause scrapie?" (1) was not intended to suggest benzene poisoning is the sole cause of scrapie.

So-called TSE's (Transmissible Spongiform Encephalopathies) can only be demonstrated to be transmissible with great difficulty. There is therefore a body of opinion that concludes the diseases are degenerative conditions influenced by a variety of environmental factors.

Professor Ebringer suggests bacteria as a factor (2) and he may well be correct. My suggestion of benzene as a factor is supported by a number of circumstances including current day geographical location of disease "hot spots" in the UK and Scandinavian.

We must also be aware that only a small percentage of "scrapie" cases are ever conclusively proven as such. It would therefore be reasonable to suggest that at least some of the reported cases are misdiagnosed lead poisoning (saturnine encephalopathy) or copper deficiency (swayback).

William M Snape BSc
Preston
Lancashire


References

1. Snape, William M. (2003). Does benzene poisoning cause scrapie?
See CORRESPONDENCE Homepage, Filed 9 January 03, www.land-care.org.uk, Click Here to View

2. Ebringer, Alan (2003). Benzene poisoning unlikely to be a factor in causing scrapie.
See CORRESPONDENCE Homepage, Filed 27 January 03, www.land-care.org.uk, Click Here to View

Further Reading Recommended by Land-Care

Scrapie statistics for Great Britain
See TSE Homepage, filed 2002, www.land-care.org.uk, Click Here to View